Layton’s Mystery Journey (3DS) review

Nintendo / Level-5
3DS, iOS, Android (3DS version reviewed)

I remember back in November 2008 when Professor Layton And The Curious Village was released on the DS in the UK.

The DS was massively successful at the time, partly thanks to the likes of Brain Training and partly thanks to the fact the Wii was doing similar degrees of gangbusters.

As such, following a TV ad campaign, the first Professor Layton game sold out all over the UK and became nigh-on impossible to buy until well after Christmas.

Now, here we are nearly a decade later and it’s fair to say the situation has changed. Nintendo is once again massively popular thanks to the Switch and 3DS, but the Layton series doesn’t appear to have enjoyed the same continued success.

Instead, Layton’s Mystery Journey is out tomorrow and it’s fair to say social media isn’t exactly white hot with hype surrounding it.

It’s strange. Despite being the seventh game in the series (eighth if you count the Phoenix Wright crossover), it’s still the same formula.

You could argue it should be just as popular for that reason, but it’s more realistic to argue the opposite: a lack of evolution has meant all but the most dedicated Layton fans have had their fill by now.

Layton’s Mystery Journey is an attempt to mix things up: if not in terms of general game mechanics, at least in terms of plot.

For the first time in the series, players won’t be following the adventures of Professor Herschel Layton. Instead, his daughter Katrielle takes over the spotlight.

The prof’s disappeared, you see, and Katrielle is keen to find out what’s happened to him. In the meantime, she’s set up her own detective agency… sounds like she’d rather she was Phoenix Wright’s daughter instead.

Katrielle is joined by her assistant Ernest – a wee sap who fills the Luke role perfectly – and a talking dog called Sherl O. C. Kholmes (ugh) who has amnesia and tags along in the hope that Katrielle can find out more about his past.

Rather than one lengthy adventure split into chapters as in the previous games, Layton’s Mystery Journey instead consists of a bunch of smaller cases – look, are we sure she isn’t Phoenix Wright’s lassie? – all with an overarching theme, one involving the seven most influential people in London.

The structure may be different, but the actual process is the same: you travel from area to area speaking to people and solving puzzles while trying to crack the mystery you’re currently working on.

As ever, puzzles are introduced in the most tenuous ways imaginable (“what a fine day we’re having, young Miss: by the way, here’s a fucking puzzle for no reason”), and as ever these puzzles are the meat of the game.

While there are a few more of these puzzles than there usually are in Layton games, it also feels like there’s a higher proportion of poor ones.

It seems to overdo it a little with the ‘trick question’ types of puzzle, where you have to think of an answer but it’s actually – nudge, wink – something a lot simpler than you were expecting.

That’s all well and good once or twice but the “fool me once” rule comes into effect here: they pull the trick so often that it starts to become the first thing you expect.

The story’s also a little disappointing. While Katrielle is a likeable character and I look forward to her hopefully appearing in more games, the general plot’s still underwhelming.

Without spoiling anything, nothing really major happens in terms of Katrielle’s character development or her situation: she just solves a bunch of cases.

As the credits roll you get the feeling you’ve just played through a big prologue for a follow-up game, and the post-credits sequence only cements that belief.

One other addition you may or may not be happy with, depending on your opinion on this sort of thing, is the presence of paid DLC.

There are five downloadable outfits at launch, each of which costs £1.79 (or £7.19 for all five) and come with a new puzzle.

Not to worry, though: if you’re a cheapskate like me the usual daily puzzles will still be available throughout the game’s first year and should be free.

In all, Layton’s Mystery Journey is a mixed bag. Fans of the series who are happy to just get more puzzles and plot should be content with this: by no means is it the best game in the series, but it should do the trick if you’ve played all the other entries.

If you haven’t, you might want to try older Layton games like The Lost Future first, because they do a far better job when it comes to storytelling.

Layton’s Mystery Journey is out now, priced £34.99 / $39.99 on the 3DS eShop. You can also buy the physical version from Amazon UK.

In order that I could write this review, I received a free copy of the game from a PR. The content of my review and the opinions therein were in no way positively influenced by this.

If you enjoyed these reviews and want to help me write them more frequently, please consider donating to my Patreon account.

Alternatively, if you’re a UK reader and can’t afford to support me on Patreon, please do your normal Amazon UK shopping via this linkTired Old Hack is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites.


  1. Interesting. Which ones would you say deliver a good story? For me, only Lost Future and Azran Legacy did. Others started well and the arse-pull endings undermined them (Curious Village, Pandora’s Box) or just… didn’t have great plots (Spectre’s Call, Miracle Mask).

  2. “Without spoiling anything, nothing really major happens in terms of Katrielle’s character development or her situation: she just solves a bunch of cases. As the credits roll you get the feeling you’ve just played through a big prologue for a follow-up game, and the post-credits sequence only cements that belief.”

    This is the reason I’m not playing it. I have been an absolute diehard Layton fan for the entire series, but Level-5 are seriously annoying me here. They’ve got rid of the old main character in the most cliché way, and, by the sounds of it, don’t bother to make any headway into his disappearance. There’s so much more story that could be told with the original Layton cast, and I’d much rather that than this new rubbish. Who’s the mother, by the way? Is that ever explained? Probably not. I want answers to the plot, not a game that wastes my time for 20 hours then says “buy the next one, and we might reveal some more”.

  3. I’ve been really intrigued by this series of games. Although maybe I’m thinking of the Ace Attorney series. What blows my mind is that people seem to love being an attorney in a video game – totally caught me off guard! I’ve never tried those though – is this related to that same series? A spin-off title featuring Professor Layton’s daughter Katrielle? The gameplay screenshots and your description seems mad fun but I have no idea what I’m getting into here, and I don’t want to spoil the game by watching a Let’s Play!

    1. Ace Attorney relates to the Layton series only when they were joined together in the crossover title: Professor Layton Vs. Phoenix Wright (3DS). Otherwise, they have been completely separate game franchises by completely different developers. If the description make Layton’s Mystery Journey seem fun to you, then it probably will be. If you don’t mind hundreds of mind-bending puzzles in-between dialogues of kooky characters fulfilling duties to an overarching narrative. The Ace Attorney games will actually have you investigate crime scenes as well as take part in the defense side of the criminal proceedings in a very fun way. The Layton series is also notable for its engaging mini-games in which success in those will bring benefits in the main game so they are not just throwaway side games. Whichever you decide to play, all games from both franchises are playable on 3DS.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.